I have had continual trouble with primer through my entire hobby experience. Some of it comes from, it seems, always having the time and inclination to paint at the exact opposite time when its good to prime things – when its warm, super-humid and generally gross outside.
But beyond that, several brands of primer have given me pretty bad results under the best of conditions. I flat out don’t use Armory-brand primer anymore (the stuff with the Dork Tower characters on the label) after a simple prime job left me trying to strip the paint off about 30 miniatures…twice. Very, very grainy, it looked like my models had been caked in white dirt. This was despite waiting for perfect conditions, shaking way more than any reasonable can of paint can require, etc. Just bad stuff. The Citadel primer (sold by GW) is off and on – sometimes it works well enough, sometimes it doesn’t.
Following the recommendation from some other people, I’m now trying a two-fold experiment. First is switching to Krylon brand primers – perhaps a company that specializes in selling spray paint will, well, make good spray paint. I’m also trying their grey primer.
The reason for this second part is driven mostly by the Huntsmen color scheme – green and white. It doesn’t matter much what color the Green side gets primed, since between the strong foundation colors Citadel puts out, a coat or two of Dark Angels green, a wash and highlighting, its pretty clear the color is green. White on the other hand is tricky – you can’t highlight pure white, because how are you going to paint on a color that’s a lighter shade of pure white? So all the definition in the model is based on highlighting. This is mostly done with grey, so it seems to make sense rather than painting over a layer of white, just skip straight to the grey. The one risk seems to me that while white primer you missed while basecoating stands out, and black primer just looks like a shadow, grey primer may be really noticeable. We’ll see how it comes out when painting.
I’ll say this though: The first batch went on smooth and even, and I’m pretty pleased with the Krylon stuff. We’ll see how it handles metal later.


